Questions and Answers
Why use haXe? Any real world samples of haXe? What's the difference between FDT and Flash Builder?
Video Transcript
00:00our Power Flasher GitHub account. So, if you actually just go to our sources here,
00:04you'll find the sources available for this.
00:08For all these projects I'm using here, check it out, or I'm sure you just Google
00:12GitHub Power Flasher, and it'll pop right up.
00:16This is the question that I have in my head, because I saw when you said that you had a
00:20title of a hack. Sorry, that's all you're supposed to say. I had no idea what it
00:24was. I did a Google search, and then I decided, you know what, I'm going to stay knowing
00:28something about it, so I'll ask the right questions instead of asking it after I actually know
00:32what I'm talking about. So, my question is, why would I
00:36want to actually do hacks? Why not just stay with the programming
00:40language? If I'm in JavaScript, why not just work in JavaScript? What are
00:45the big advantage of working with hacks?
00:49I think that is just an amazing question, and I think that's something
00:53that every person should ask themselves.
00:57For some people, hacks is not the right way to go.
01:01They'll just be like, why would I do that?
01:05It's a personal preference we've actually had at the Power Flasher
01:09Agency. We have some people who just, maybe they...
01:13For example, I used the JavaScript example.
01:17Some people, it just drives them nuts writing JavaScript.
01:21They just do not like it. They're prejudiced. I'm
01:25not using words in their mouth. Let me get the idea. They just don't want to deal with it. They hate it.
01:29And they do kind of like the idea of having an editor, of using
01:33a syntax that's more similar to ActionScript
01:37to generate the JavaScript code for you.
01:41I do think, I will say, I'll be totally honest, that I think
01:45if you're just doing a small thing, a small project, do it in JavaScript.
01:49And again, we're talking more about the JavaScript example.
01:53I've never even started JavaScript. However, I know a guy who's...
01:57His name's James Jackson. You can check him out on Twitter and on the web.
02:01He is building a massive, massive cloud platform.
02:05I will say he is working with a really massive
02:09project. And he's
02:13a very proficient JavaScript programmer. And he's very comfortable.
02:18He actually relaxed the idea of writing it in HEX. Because he's got hundreds
02:22of classes. It's a massive, massive project. And for him,
02:26it makes him much more efficient to write it in HEX than
02:30doing it all in JavaScript.
02:34So really, I'm getting out of it that a lot of it is just the workflow.
02:38So if you're more comfortable with the structured workflow, then obviously
02:42you don't have to worry about if it's PHP, which is much harder to get all the
02:46classes and names and structures versus needing to remember it by heart or googling
02:50it each time. You just get that convenience of the same structure. Even though
02:54the application that you're building is custom built for PHP. So if I'm building
02:58this HEX project and it's going to be for PHP, it's not going to be that easy
03:02for me to refactor it and make it good for Flash and good for
03:06JavaScript, right? It's not about making it easy for you to cross
03:10between languages more than making it easier for you to work in the same workflow and the same
03:14type of mythologies. Would that be an accurate statement? Yeah. Yes.
03:18That's exactly what I would say. I think some people talk about...
03:23I've heard this. Even within the HEX community, there's people who
03:27disagree with each other on how to use HEX. Some say, oh, I just want to have one
03:31code base. That's it. Then push out the mobile platforms. And other people
03:35are like, eh, I like having my PHP HEX project
03:39and my JavaScript HEX project. I'll keep the platform separate.
03:43So I would definitely say that
03:47it's nice, though, when you do share... There are some libraries that you can share.
03:51Like, for example, if you have a math library. That's platform agnostic.
03:55Just maybe some calculations or some methods that you've
03:59done that you want to share between different platforms. That's totally doable.
04:03So especially between Flash and JavaScript and C++.
04:07Or you have a...
04:12I know that there's a port of rubber-penner signals for HEX. I think it's called
04:16a hustle, like HXL. And that is...
04:20So you can actually use that same messaging system
04:24for Flash, for JavaScript, and for C++ even. And even
04:28I think Nico, possibly even PHP. So you can actually have the same
04:32way of having this way of working with events.
04:36One library for all these different platforms.
04:43Very interesting. So just a couple more questions from our guests. Real world
04:48application...
04:52Well, let me just stutter a little bit. But basically, are there a lot
04:56of real case applications? Or is it kind of hard to know who's actually
05:00using HEX? And are there any sample projects of big sites
05:04or big implementations of something that we know that they're using HEX?
05:08And we could learn from their experience. Yeah, I think the best thing to do would be to
05:12check out the HEX.org website. They have a few...
05:17It's kind of old. It hasn't been updated for a little bit. The guys are working on the
05:21API right now. There are some examples there.
05:25There's a HEX group on Google+, and there's a few guys
05:29on Twitter floating around who talk about their projects.
05:33But you're all right. It is a little tough to know because they
05:37write in HEX, and they don't... When you go to a website, they don't advertise,
05:41hey, this is, by the way, this is written in JavaScript HEX.
05:46That doesn't really happen too much. Actually, it doesn't happen at all. No one's going to advertise that.
05:50I do know that among game developers
05:54that there's a ton of guys using HEX for game
05:58development for Swift. There's that there.
06:02So, there was another question which I think you already answered was
06:06basically, could HEX convert C++ code to ActionScript 3?
06:10So, it seems like the answer is no because it's really more
06:14I wouldn't even know how to call this.
06:19It's more like a... There's actually quite a lot of languages that try to do this, but basically it's a language
06:24where you build your application and it converts itself into whatever
06:29output you need it to be, but vice versa, it doesn't go the other way around.
06:33It's not like Adobe's attempt with Wallaby or other
06:37applications that try to convert from one programming language to another programming language.
06:43Unless you have something to add that I could ask the big question
06:47of the day, which obviously I think everyone was really excited about this topic.
06:51It was really interesting. And the next question would be, and you could always answer the first one as well.
06:55The next question would be, what is really the difference between
06:59Flash Builder and FDT, which is a question that Shammy had.
07:03By the way, Shammy, send us an email at
07:06www.everythingaffiliate.com and for a little gift as well. So, whoever talked publicly
07:11today, just send us an email and we'll figure out with you something from our
07:14goodie bag. We actually have quite a lot of stuff in the goodie bag, so we'll be
07:17relatively generous because almost no one actually did the Twitter stuff.
07:21Yeah. Okay. So, the first... Oh yeah. So, if you remember what I was talking to earlier
07:28about trying to introduce the... I know it was kind of like a fire hose here of information
07:33here. I kind of let off. For the hex, it's kind of in the case of hex to Flash, it's a compiler.
07:42You have script, output by code. But for the other targets, I would say it's more
07:48better to call it a script generator or a code generator. So, that's kind of how...
07:55It's outputting JavaScript code. It's outputting PHP code. It's outputting C++ code.
08:01So yeah, you're right. It's not like an in-between, some kind of
08:05conglomerate or together. It's just you write hex and then you can generate
08:11JavaScript, PHP, C++ code. Or in the case of Flash, Iniko actually compile, of course compile in
08:19the sense of we take source code and generate a binary, a Swift, or a Iniko... I think it's
08:27called NK files, like that they just execute. All right. So, the next one is difference
08:34between Flash Builder and FCT. That's... I mean, I get that all the time. And let me just open up here.
08:42So, the biggest difference is... The easiest way to answer that is we have a live parser
08:51that does not exist with Flash Builder. So, if you ever used Flash Builder that...
08:58Just go ahead and do this. If you have, if you download, download something like that.
09:02You create a file and you type in Flash Builder, you're not going to know that
09:08all this code I'm doing my screen here is breaking my application until I save.
09:14And when I do save, you only get one error back at a time.
09:18And that's because how Flash Builder works is that it actually saves your file,
09:23generates a Swift, and then whatever error the Swift says to you, that's what it tells you back.
09:29So, that's why, like for this example, if my screen is still active, which I think it is,
09:33you know, I have five errors here. Flash Builder, you really would have one error
09:37coming back to you at a time. And you'd be like, oh wait, okay, it says I have this
09:40code as well, so get rid of that. Then you have to compile again and be like, oh, okay,
09:43there's a line here. Okay, okay. And then I would save that. Whereas for FTT, it's actually,
09:50it's always, we have this parser, it's always running while you type. And so that enables
09:55you to very quickly write code and find mistakes really fast. There's one, that's probably the
10:02biggest example. And then the other one is that we have a lot more quick fixes and quick
10:08assist available to you and advanced refactoring. Like for example, you know, I could do things like,
10:14let's see here, extract a constant variable out, right? Or let's see here, I can do things like
10:21select a block of code and extract a method, right? Do things like that. You know, I have
10:29things like, you know, 10, like can we just do a 10? Two, well, you can do things like
10:35extracting local variables. So you have a lot more of those things available to you.
10:40Other things like quick fixes, quick assist. So we have something like, what was it? I think 35 or 40
10:47of things that you can do to quick fix or quick assist to generate code for you.
10:54So that's, I'd say that's definitely it. So actually, I'll show one real quick. I'll show,
10:59go ahead and talk. I'll show a quick one. Obviously, one of the bigger advantages it
11:06starts free, you get almost everything, which is really cool and exciting.
11:11All right, this is actually an interesting question that we didn't really ask anyone, but
11:15can I limit my application to only work on some mobile devices such as only on the Kindle Fire?
11:21So all this time we were talking about building it for Android in general, but is there a way
11:25to make sure that your application will only be presented for people with specific devices?
11:30It's such a specific question that, you know, it is a good question, though, such as the Kindle Fire
11:36just coming out and people wanting to develop just for the Kindle Fire. I think we just have to do
11:41a little bit more of research on it, but I think that doesn't depend on our development itself. It
11:46depends on the actual platform that sells the applications. So if the application has some
11:51configurations that enable you only to show it for people that have specific devices, I think
11:56Amazon does have that. I'm not sure about if Apple has that configuration or not, if you could sell
12:01it only for your iPad, or I'm not sure. That's just something you have to research into and
12:07figure out as you figure out what applications you want your app to run on. By the way, Chris
12:13sent us answers to most of the questions, so we'll post them up on our website hopefully
12:18later this week, but he had some good answers. And again, anyone that is in our event is going
12:24to get a free book. Well, it's not a printed book, but it's an e-book from O'Reilly. We'll send you
12:32information about that in an email.
